The Commission on Capital Cases updates this information regularly. This information, however, is subject to change and may not reflect the latest status of an inmate’s case and should not be relied on for statistical or legal purposes.
SCOTT, Paul William (W/M)
AKA: Steven William Prince; George Curtis Cook, Jr.; Ray Justice; Alberto Justice.; Rex Cole
DC # 071615
DOB: 05/09/56
Fifteenth Judicial Circuit, Palm Beach County, Case #79-167
Sentencing Judge: The Honorable Vaughn J. Rudnick
Trial Attorney: Gordon Barrs – Assistant Public Defender
Attorney, Direct Appeal: Robert M. Leen
Attorney, Collateral Appeals: Stephen J. Finta – Registry
Date of Offense: 12/04/78
Date of Sentence: 12/14/79
Circumstances of Offense:
On the evening of 12/04/78, the defendant, Paul Scott, and his codefendant, Richard Kondian, murdered James Alessi in his home. A witness, Charles Soutullo, claimed he was asked to participate in a scheme to rob and murder the victim, but refused. The victim, who knew both men, picked up Scott and Kondian and later returned with them to his home.
Alessi’s nude body was found on a sofa in his home on 12/05/78. He was covered with blood and his hands and feet were tightly bound with electrical cord and telephone wire. Alessi had been beaten in the head, chest and on the arms. One blow to the head was so severe that it caused a compressed skull fracture. The cause of death was determined to be a result of the head injuries.
Evidence indicated a violent struggle took place and attempts were made by the victim to free himself. Throughout the home, there were broken articles and bloodstains were on the walls, furniture, curtains and floors. Scott’s fingerprints were found on various items throughout the home, including the neck of a broken vase and a bloodstained knife found on the sofa where the victim’s body was found.
After beating Alessi to death, Scott and Kondian rummaged through his house. They later entered his florist and jewelry shop with a key and seized most of the gold jewelry. They also stole Alessi’s car. Scott was apprehended in Sacramento, California, one month after the murder. At the time of his arrest, Scott had in his possession a golden bear charm that was identical to the one that belonged to the victim. Kondian was in Rhode Island when he learned of the warrant issued for his arrest. He surrendered to the Rhode Island police on 12/06/78.
Additional Information:
At the time of this offense, Scott was an absconder from parole supervision in California for second-degree murder.
Codefendant Information:
Kondian, Richard Jr. (Palm Beach County, Case #79-0167)
On 02/06/80, Kondian was sentenced to 45 years for murder in the second degree. Kondian was paroled on 02/08/94. He is presently under supervision in Rhode Island, and his parole is not scheduled to expire until 11/28/23.
Trial Summary:
01/05/79 Scott was arrested in Sacramento, California.
01/08/79 Scott was returned to Palm Beach County, Florida.
01/17/79 The defendant was indicted on the following:
Count I: First-Degree Murder (James Alessi)
10/10/79 Scott was found guilty by the trial jury of first-degree murder as charged in the indictment.
10/24/79 Upon advisory sentencing, the trial jury, by a 7 to 5 majority, voted for the death penalty.
12/14/79 Defendant was sentenced as follows:
Count I: First-Degree Murder (James Alessi) – Death
Appellate Summary:
Florida Supreme Court – Direct Appeal
FSC #58,588
411 So. 2d 866
01/31/80 Appeal filed.
03/11/82 Florida Supreme Court affirmed the conviction and sentence of death.
09/13/82 Motion for rehearing denied.
10/20/82 Mandate issued.
Florida Supreme Court – Petition for Writ of Habeas Corpus
FSC #63,736
433 So. 2d 974
05/31/83 Petition filed.
06/03/83 FSC denied petition.
United States District Court, Southern District – Petition for Writ of Habeas Corpus
USDC #83-8293
686 F. Supp. 1488
06/03/83 Petition filed.
06/06/83 Permanent Stay of Execution to allow time to seek relief in State Court.
12/11/87 Amended Petition for Writ of Habeas Corpus filed.
05/26/88 Petition denied.
06/05/88 Stay of Execution vacated.
Circuit Court – 3.850 Motion
CC #79-167
02/16/84 Motion filed.
03/13/84 Motion denied.
Florida Supreme Court – 3.850 Appeal
FSC# 65,060
464 So. 2d 1171
03/26/84 Appeal filed.
01/10/85 FSC affirmed the Trial Court’s denial of the 3.850 Motion.
04/04/85 Motion for rehearing denied.
05/14/85 Mandate issued.
Circuit Court – 3.850 Motion
CC # 79-167
12/27/85 Motion filed.
07/23/86 Motion denied.
Florida Supreme Court – 3.850 Appeal
FSC #69,341
513 So. 2d 653
09/17/86 Appeal filed.
08/20/87 FSC affirmed the Trial Court’s denial of the 3.850 Motion.
10/28/87 Motion for rehearing denied.
12/07/87 Mandate issued.
United States Court of Appeals, 11th Circuit – Appeal of Habeas Denial
USCA #88-5536
891 F. 2d 800
06/05/88 Appeal filed.
12/14/89 USCA affirmed the denial of Scott’s Petition for Writ of Habeas Corpus.
United States Supreme Court – Petition for Writ of Certiorari
USSC# 89-7732
498 U.S. 881
06/08/90 Petition filed.
10/01/90 USSC denied petition.
Florida Supreme Court – Petition for Writ of Habeas Corpus
FSC #76,831
634 So. 2d 1062
10/26/90 Petition filed.
11/04/93 Petition denied.
04/12/94 Motion for rehearing denied.
04/12/94 Mandate issued.
Circuit Court – 3.850 Motion
CC #79-167
12/18/90 Motion filed.
03/06/91 Motion denied.
Florida Supreme Court – 3.850 Appeal
FSC #77,756
634 So. 2d 1062
04/18/91 Appeal filed.
11/04/93 FSC affirmed the Trial Court’s denial of the 3.850 Motion.
02/24/94 Motion for rehearing denied.
04/12/94 Second Motion for rehearing denied. Mandate issued.
Circuit Court – 3.850 Motion
CC #79-167
10/31/94 Motion filed.
11/08/94 Motion denied.
United States District Court, Middle District of Florida – Petition for Writ of Habeas Corpus, (Rule 60(b) Motion)
USDC #94-1094 & #94-2367
10/31/94 Appeal filed, Transferred to US District Court, Southern District.
11/07/94 USDC denied the Rule 60(b) motion and granted a Certificate of Probable Cause.
11/10/94 USDC vacated Certificate of Probable Cause.
United States Court of Appeals, Eleventh Circuit – Habeas Appeal
USCA #94-5313
38 F. 3d 1547
11/02/94 Appeal filed.
11/14/94 USCA affirmed the District Court’s denial of the Habeas Petition.
11/17/94 Rehearing denied.
Florida Supreme Court – 3.850 Appeal
FSC #84,686
657 So. 2d 1129
11/09/94 Appeal filed.
03/16/95 FSC reversed the Trial Court’s denial of 3.850 Motion and remanded for the purpose of an evidentiary hearing.
07/20/95 Motion for rehearing denied.
08/21/95 Mandate issued.
Florida Supreme Court – Petition for Writ of Habeas Corpus
FSC #84,687
657 So. 2d 1129
11/14/94 Petition filed.
03/16/95 Petition denied.
07/20/95 Motion for rehearing denied.
United States Supreme Court – Petition for Writ of Certiorari
USSC# 94-8888
515 U.S. 1145
04/13/95 Petition filed.
06/19/95 Petition denied.
08/22/95 Mandate issued.
Circuit Court – 3.850 Motion, On Remand from the Florida Supreme Court
CC #79-167
04/23/96 Motion denied
Florida Supreme Court – 3.850 Appeal
FSC #88,551
717 So. 2d 908
07/22/96 Appeal filed.
03/26/98 FSC affirmed the Trial Court’s denial of the 3.850 Motion.
06/15/98 Motion for rehearing denied.
07/16/98 Mandate issued.
United States Supreme Court – Petition for Writ of Certiorari
USSC #98-6081
525 U.S. 972
09/14/98 Petition filed.
11/02/98 Petition denied.
Circuit Court – 3.850 Motion
CC #79-167
06/23/03 Motion filed.
10/21/03 Motion denied.
Circuit Court – 3.853 Motion
CC #79-167
12/14/05 Motion filed.
03/20/06 Motion amended.
06/07/06 Second amended motion.
08/14/06 Circuit Court denied motion.
Florida Supreme Court – 3.853 Appeal
FSC# 07-1734
46 So.3d 529
09/18/07 Appeal filed.
09/03/09 Oral Arguments held.
10/15/09 Denial of 3.853 Motion affirmed.
01/27/10 Mandate issued.
Warrants:
05/12/82 Death Warrant signed by Governor Bob Graham.
06/06/83 United States District Court granted a Stay of Execution.
10/19/90 Second Death Warrant signed by Governor Bob Graham.
10/29/90 Florida Supreme Court granted a Stay of Execution.
09/30/94 Third Death Warrant signed by Governor Lawton Chiles.
11/18/94 Florida Supreme Court granted a Stay of Execution.
Clemency:
03/31/83 Clemency hearing held.
Factors Contributing to the Delay in Imposition of the Sentence:
The delay in this case is a result of the number of appeals filed. The defendant’s direct appeal was filed in 1980. He has subsequently filed numerous motions in circuit court and Habeas Petitions with the State Supreme Court. The appeals all appear to have been handled expeditiously, and in the appropriate court, however; there were numerous appeals for the courts to consider.
Case Information:
On 01/31/80, Scott filed a Direct Appeal in the Florida Supreme Court. In his direct appeal, Scott argued several issues. First, he argued that the evidence provided by the State was insufficient to prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt and did not exclude a reasonable hypothesis of innocence. He also contended that evidence did not support a finding of premeditation, robbery or burglary. Scott argued that error occurred when the court sustained the State’s objection on the basis of irrelevance to the question asked of a State witness by defense counsel. Scott also argued that the court gave erroneous jury instructions on the felony-murder rule and that jury selection occurred on a Jewish religious holiday, excluding a segment of the community from selection. He argued that the court erred in finding that the murder occurred during the commission of, or attempt to commit robbery and/or burglary, and was for pecuniary gain and was cruel. Scott’s final arguments were that a journalist was erroneously excluded from providing testimony and that Florida’s death penalty statute is unconstitutional. The court found no merit in Scott arguments and affirmed his conviction and sentence of death on 10/20/82.
Scott then filed both a Petition for Writ Habeas Corpus on 05/31/83. The petition was denied on 06/03/83.
On 06/03/83, Scott filed a federal Petition for Writ of Habeas Corpus in the United District Court. The District Court granted a Stay of Execution to allow Scott to seek relief in state court on 06/06/83. On 05/26/88, the petition was denied and the stay of execution was vacated on 06/05/88.
Scott then filed his first 3.850 Motion in Circuit Court on 02/16/84. This motion was immediately denied without prejudice, because the Trial Court claimed the defendant did not properly swear to the motion.
On 03/26/84, Scott filed a 3.850 Appeal in the Florida Supreme Court. The Florida Supreme Court affirmed the denial of Scott’s 3.850 Motion on 01/10/85.
Scott then filed the corrected 3.850 Motion on 12/27/85. The main issue raised was ineffective assistance of counsel. The trial court denied this motion on 07/23/86.
On 09/17/86, Scott filed a 3.850 Appeal in the Florida Supreme Court. The court affirmed the denial of Scott’s 3.850 Motion on 08/20/87.
Scott filed a Habeas Appeal in the United States Court of Appeals, 11th Circuit on 06/05/88. The court affirmed the denial of Scott’s Habeas Appeal on 12/14/89.
On 06/08/90, Scott filed a Petition for Writ of Certiorari. The petition was denied on 10/01/90.
The Governor signed Scott’s second death warrant on 10/19/90. The Florida Supreme Court granted a stay on 10/29/90 to allow new postconviction counsel the opportunity to file a second 3.850 Motion.
Scott filed a Petition for Writ of Habeas Corpus on 10/26/90. The petition was denied on 11/04/93.
Scott subsequently filed another 3.850 in Circuit Court on 12/18/90. Scott asserted that relief should be granted on account that allegedly new statements had been made by his codefendant and a witness had recanted his testimony. The trial court denied relief on 03/06/91 without an evidentiary hearing.
On 04/18/91, Scott filed a 3.850 Appeal in the Florida Supreme Court. In the appeal, Scott made several claims. First, he claimed that error occurred in the Circuit Court ruling on his second 3.850 Motion without holding an evidentiary hearing. Next, he claimed that newly discovered evidence established his innocence. He also contended that his codefendant’s sentence of 45 years rendered his disproportionate, he was erroneously denied an opportunity to present exculpatory evidence and he was denied effective assistance of counsel. Scott’s final claims were that the prosecutor improperly argued inapplicable aggravating factors, and his sentence was unconstitutionally founded on arbitrary, capricious, and impermissible evidence. On 02/24/94, the court found Scott’s appeal to be without merit and affirmed the denial of his 3.850 Motion.
A third death warrant was signed by Governor Lawton Chiles on 09/30/94. The Florida Supreme Court granted a stay of execution on 11/18/94.
Scott filed his fourth 3.850 Motion on 10/31/94. Scott claimed there was newly-discovered evidence and the State violated the Brady rule. (Brady V. Maryland, 373 U.S. 83.) Scott alleged that the State violated the rule by not disclosing a statement made by a cellmate of Richard Kondian, his codefendant. The inmate claimed he told an officer that Kondian admitted to killing the victim. Scott also claimed that another inmate related to police that Kondian stated he was angry with Scott for “running out on him” and not participating in the murder. The motion was denied on 11/08/94.
On 10/31/94, Scott also filed a Petition for Writ of Habeas Corpus in the United States Circuit Court. On 11/07/94, the court denied the Rule 60(b) and granted a Certificate of Probable Cause. The Certificate was denied on 11/10/94.
On 11/02/94, Scott filed a Habeas Appeal in the United States Court of Appeals. The court affirmed the denial of Scott’s Habeas Petition on 11/14/94.
Scott filed a 3.850 Appeal in the Florida Supreme Court on 11/09/94. On 03/16/95, the Florida Supreme Court concluded that the trial court erred in failing to hold an evidentiary hearing on these issues and remanded the case to the trial court for an evidentiary hearing.
On 11/14/94, Scott filed a Petition for Writ of Habeas Corpus in the Florida Supreme Court. The petition was denied on 03/16/95.
Scott then filed a Petition for Writ of Certiorari in the United States Supreme Court. The petition was denied on 06/19/95.
On 04/23/96, Scott’s remanded 3.850 Motion to the Circuit Court was denied.
Scott appealed the Circuit Court’s decision to the Florida Supreme Court on 07/22/96. In his 3.850 Appeal, he claimed that the court erred in allowing the assistant state counsel to serve as both prosecutor and witness and erred in denying his seven motions to disqualify the judge. He also claimed that error occurred in the scheduling of the evidentiary hearing, holding the hearing without him present and denying his motions to continue the hearing and to depose certain witnesses. Scott also claimed that the trial court erroneously excluded certain evidence from the evidentiary hearing and that he was denied effective assistance of counsel. The court disagreed with all of Scott’s claims. On 03/26/98, the court affirmed the denial of Scott’s 3.850 Motion.
On 09/14/98, Scott filed a Petition for Writ of Certiorari to the United States Court. The petition was denied on 11/02/98.
On 06/23/03, Scott filed another 3.850 Motion in the State Circuit Court. The motion was denied on 10/21/03.
Scott filed a 3.853 Motion in the State Circuit Court on 12/14/05 and amended the motion on 03/20/06. Scott amended the 3.853 motion a second time on 06/07/06. On 08/14/06, the Circuit Court denied the motion.
On 09/18/07, Scott filed a Notice of Appeal in the Florida Supreme Court regarding the 3.853 motion denied by the Circuit Court. Oral arguments were held on 09/03/09. On 10/15/09, the Florida Supreme Court affirmed the denial of the motion. A mandate was issued on 01/27/10.
Institutional Adjustment:
DATE DAYS VIOLATION LOCATION
-------- ---- ---------------------------- -------------------
12/14/80 30 DISOBEYING ORDER FSP
03/10/81 0 POSS OF NEGOTIABLES FSP
12/07/82 0 ATTEMPT TO CONSPIRE CENTRAL OFFICE
02/08/83 0 DISORDERLY CONDUCT CENTRAL OFFICE
06/14/85 0 DISRESP.TO OFFICIALS INDIAN RIVER C. I.
05/10/89 30 POSS OF WEAPONS FSP
06/17/91 0 DISOBEYING ORDER FSP
03/07/93 0 POSS OF WEAPONS FSP
05/12/94 0 POSS OF NARCOTICS UNION C. I.
11/10/99 0 UNAUTH USE OF DRUGS UNION C. I.
12/07/99 0 POSS OF CONTRABAND UNION C. I.
09/20/02 0 LYING TO STAFF UNION C. I.
_______________________________________________________________________
Report Date: 12/01/00 WHS
Updated: 04/12/11 EMJ